Is now a good time to sell your home in Andersonville, Chicago? The Andersonville Chicago real estate sales I reviewed show strong results for both condos and houses. Over the last 12 months, 77% of Andersonville condos sold above asking price, and the typical one went under contract in 6 days. Two out of three vintage single-family houses sold over asking, usually in about 8 days.
Those results give homeowners a good reason to consider selling. They do not tell me what your home should be listed for or whether the timing works for you. A two-bedroom condo off Clark Street and a brand new house on Summerdale need different comparisons and different plans.
I reviewed closed MLS sales to see what buyers paid, how quickly homes went under contract, and where sellers needed more time. Here is how I would use those findings to help you prepare for a sale.
I reviewed every closed sale in my Andersonville search area from mid-November 2025 through early November 2026. I used the same area I describe in my guide to living in Andersonville: Foster Avenue to Bryn Mawr Avenue, from Broadway west to Ravenswood Avenue. These are the boundaries for this research, and other websites may use a different area.
I separated condos from single-family houses so you can see how each market performed. The figures below describe homes that closed during the research period. Before advising you on a list price, I would also review the homes buyers can choose from today.
Type of home | Sales | Median price | Sold over asking | Typical days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Condos and townhomes | 44 | $466,500 | 77% | 6 |
Single-family houses | 21 | $1,275,000 | 57% | 12 |
Source: MLS (MRED), closed sales November 14, 2025 to November 3, 2026, within Foster, Bryn Mawr, Broadway and Ravenswood. At the time of research, deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
The typical Andersonville condo sold for 105.4% of its list price. On a $450,000 asking price, that works out to about $24,000 over asking. None of the 44 condo sales took 60 days or more to go under contract.
These results show competition among buyers for the condos that sold. Selling above asking also depends on where a home was priced at the start. I would use comparable sales to advise you on a price rather than assume an above-asking sale is guaranteed.
The broader Edgewater figures were different: 36% of condos sold over asking, and the typical one took 15 days. Edgewater includes the high-rise buildings along Sheridan Road, so its overall figures cover a different mix of homes. For an Andersonville seller, I would begin with nearby properties that buyers would realistically compare with yours.
Vintage greystones and gardens on a tree-lined Andersonville block.
Two-bedroom condos had especially strong results in this research. Condos in the higher price ranges also drew competition, which is encouraging if you are thinking about selling a larger home.
Condo size | Sales | Median price | Sold over asking |
|---|---|---|---|
1 bedroom | 9 | $270,000 | 67% |
2 bedrooms | 26 | $471,500 | 85% |
3 bedrooms | 8 | $687,450 | 62% |
More than 8 out of 10 two-bedroom condos sold over asking, with a median sale price of $471,500. If you own one, that is useful evidence of buyer competition during the research period. I would then look at how your condo compares in condition, layout, parking, outdoor space, and building costs.
Of the condos that sold for $600,000 or more, 10 out of 11 went over asking, at a typical 105.9% of list price. In the $400,000 to $600,000 range, 81% sold over asking, usually in about 6 days. These groups show that competition extended across price ranges.
The top condo sale was a unit on Balmoral listed at $650,000 that sold for $775,000 in 5 days. That is a strong result, though I would need to compare the home itself before using it to advise another seller. A standout sale helps explain the market without setting an expectation for every condo.
The median monthly assessment was about $381. Buyers consider the assessment alongside their other ownership costs, so I make sure the marketing explains what it covers. That gives buyers a clearer picture when they compare your home with other listings.
My advice for condo sellers: These results support taking a closer look at selling. I would review the most relevant closed sales and current competition with you, then explain where I think your condo fits. You choose the list price after we discuss the options.
Andersonville houses also had strong results, especially vintage homes. Two out of three vintage houses sold over asking, and the typical one went under contract in about 8 days. New construction sold at higher prices and needed a longer timeline.
Type of house | Sales | Median price | Sold over asking | Typical days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Vintage houses (built before 1940) | 15 | $1,225,000 | 67% | 8 |
New construction (built 2020 or later) | 4 | $2,368,750 | 0% | 65 |
Two other house sales were built between 1940 and 2019 or had no year built listed, and are not in this table.
Vintage houses sold for a median of $1,225,000 and a typical 104.2% of their list price. One house on Magnolia, built in 1899, was listed at $1,395,000 and sold for $1,565,000 in 5 days. That sale is a useful example of the competition a vintage home can attract.
New construction sold for a median of $2,368,750, almost twice the vintage median. These homes take longer because they are priced higher and have a smaller pool of buyers at that price. The four new homes took a median of about 65 days, and none sold over asking.
I would read those new construction results in the context of their higher prices and the small group of sales. A longer marketing period needs to be part of the plan at that level. I would compare a newer house with other newer homes at similar prices before advising you.
My advice for house sellers: Vintage houses and new construction each need a plan that fits their buyers and price range. I would review your condition, features, competing homes, and preferred timeline with you. You decide the list price, and I help you understand what supports it.
A vintage Andersonville house with a front porch and a garden, the kind of home buyers have been competing for.
Mostly, yes. The part of Andersonville north of Foster Avenue is in the Edgewater community area. The blocks just south of Foster, around Clark Street, are in Uptown. Andersonville is a neighborhood name with varying boundaries, so you will see different maps.
That distinction matters when you look up home values. An Edgewater market summary includes homes beyond the Andersonville area used in this research, including Sheridan Road high-rises. Andersonville condos in my search sold over asking more than twice as often as Edgewater condos overall.
I would use those broader figures as background. For advice about your home, I would focus on the nearby properties that offer buyers a similar location, home type, and price range.
Clark Street, the heart of Andersonville, with its Swedish Dala horse.
When I show homes in Andersonville, buyers ask about daily life as well as the home itself. I want your listing to make the features and location easy to understand before a showing.
For a closer look at the area, visit my Andersonville neighborhood page. My Andersonville vs. Uptown comparison also explains the differences buyers may consider when choosing between nearby homes.
I would start with your plans, how ready your home is, and the listings buyers would compare with it. The closed sales show encouraging results for both condos and houses. Choosing a launch date also means looking at the competition when you are ready to sell.
Most condos in this research sold above asking, and the typical one went under contract in 6 days. If your condo is ready, those results give us a reason to consider listing before spring. I would review similar homes currently for sale and discuss whether more preparation would help your launch.
Vintage houses sold quickly and often over asking during the research period. For a newer house, I would allow more time because of the higher price range and compare it with other newer homes available to buyers. Both types can be strong listings with preparation and pricing that fit the home.
You decide when to sell and what price you are comfortable with. I will show you recent sales, current competition, and the options I recommend for your situation. My post on selling in winter or spring in Chicago walks through the timing question in more detail.
A strong market gives us a helpful starting point. I still want to make sure your home is ready, the pricing advice is grounded in comparable sales, and buyers can understand what makes it appealing.
My office is on Lincoln Avenue, a short drive from Andersonville, and I work on these blocks often. If you are considering a sale, I would be happy to sit down with you, review the relevant homes, and explain what I see in the numbers. You can ask questions and decide what makes sense for your plans.
For most owners, the numbers are strong. Over the last 12 months, 77% of Andersonville condos sold over asking, and the typical one went under contract in 6 days, based on the MLS. Two out of three vintage houses also sold over asking, usually in about 8 days. New construction took longer because it is priced higher.
Over the last 12 months, the median Andersonville condo sold for $466,500 and the median single-family house sold for $1,275,000. Two-bedroom condos had a median of $471,500. Prices vary by block, size, and condition.
The median time to go under contract was 6 days for condos and 12 days for houses. Vintage houses took about 8 days, and new construction took a median of about 65 days.
Mostly. The part of Andersonville north of Foster Avenue is in the Edgewater community area, and the blocks just south of Foster are in Uptown. The city does not draw an official Andersonville boundary.
The Berwyn and Bryn Mawr Red Line stations are east of Andersonville. Both were rebuilt and reopened in July 2025 with elevators and full accessibility.
If you are wondering what your Andersonville home could sell for, we can start with the recent sales and current competition. I will explain which comparisons matter and what I would recommend for preparation, pricing, and timing.
You do not need to have a listing date in mind to start that conversation. My role is to help you understand your options, and you decide when you are ready and how you want to price your home.
You can start with a free home value review or schedule a complimentary consultation. You can also take my free Chicago Home Seller Course, or call or text me at 773.719.0989.
I am Dee Savic, a Chicago Realtor® with Baird & Warner. I have more than 24 years of real estate experience, have lived in Chicago for more than 27 years, and have closed more than 300 transactions. I help buyers, sellers, downsizers, and relocation clients in Andersonville and across Chicago, including Lincoln Park, Lakeview, Lincoln Square, Ravenswood, North Center, Roscoe Village, Uptown, Edgewater, Bucktown, Wicker Park, and the Gold Coast.
Dee Savic
Realtor® | Baird & Warner
4553 N. Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60625
773.719.0989
[email protected]
deesavic.com
Seller's Advice
How much Chicago homeowners have gained, and what it can mean for your next move
Buying
Neighborhoods, getting around without a car, parking and dibs, winter, the real cost, schools, lead pipes, and property taxes, from a local since 1998
Seller Advice
What 12 months of MLS sales show for Logan Square condo and house sellers
Seller's Advice
A day-by-day checklist from a Chicago listing agent, one small step at a time
Relocation
ZooLights, Christkindlmarket, the Lights Festival, free museum days and new spots, with dates and prices
Chicago Market
What North Side 2-4 unit buildings sold for, who buys them, and how to handle tenants
Selling
What 12 months of MLS sales show for condos, vintage houses and new construction
Selling
Attorney review, inspection, appraisal, closing paperwork and moving out, step by step
Selling
My room-by-room checklist for listing photos, video and 3D tours
I'm Dee Savic, your trusted Chicago real estate expert, and I'm here to guide you through your relocation journey. Discover why Chicago is the perfect city for you; from its diverse neighborhoods to its cultural vibrancy, Chicago offers an unmatched urban experience. Together, we'll find a community and home that fits your lifestyle and aspirations.